14 Bourbons That Aren't Worth Your Money

Pappy Van Winkle 23 Year

Since The Beverage Tasting Institute gave the Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve 20 Year Old a near-perfect 99/100 score in 1998, the brand’s popularity has exploded. They now sell several expressions, from 10 up to 23 years old. These bourbons are famous for their buttery texture and long, complex finishes.

The 23-year-old is among the most sought-after. Many rave about its complexity and balanced flavor profile. Despite the quality and reputation, it retails for just under $300. But because demand far outstrips supply, getting one at retail is nearly impossible.

Most buyers end up paying over $5,000 on the secondary market—a staggering sum even for a bourbon of this caliber. Instead of shelling out that kind of money, consider more affordable bourbons with similar quality, like Old Forester Birthday Bourbon. Or try to find one of the rare bars that sell Pappy Van Winkle at retail price by the glass.